Pigeonhole Principle

From ProofWiki
Jump to: navigation, search

Theorem

Let $S$ be a finite set whose cardinality is $n$.

Let $S_1, S_2, \ldots, S_k$ be a partition of $S$ into $k$ subsets.

Then at least one subset $S_i$ of $S$ contains at least $\left \lceil {n/k} \right \rceil$ elements

where $\left \lceil {\cdot} \right \rceil$ denotes the ceiling function.


Corollary

If a set of $n$ distinct objects is partitioned into $k$ subsets, where $0 < k < n$, then at least one subset must contain at least two elements.


Proof

Suppose this were not the case, and no subset $S_i$ of $S$ has as many as $\left \lceil {n/k} \right \rceil$ elements.

Then the maximum number of elements of any $S_i$ would be $\left \lceil {n/k} \right \rceil - 1$.

So the total number of elements of $S$ would be no more than $k \left({\left \lceil {n/k} \right \rceil - 1}\right) = k \left \lceil {n/k} \right \rceil - k$.


There are two cases:


Suppose $k \mathop \backslash n$.

Then $\left \lceil {\dfrac n k} \right \rceil = \dfrac n k$ is an integer and $k \left \lceil {n/k} \right \rceil - k = n - k$.

Thus $\displaystyle \sum_{i \mathop = 1}^k \left \vert {S_i}\right \vert \le n-k < n$.

This contradicts our assumption that no subset $S_i$ of $S$ has as many as $\left \lceil {n/k} \right \rceil$ elements.


Next, suppose that $k \nmid n$.

Then:

$k \left \lceil {n/k} \right \rceil - k < \dfrac {k \left({n+k}\right)} k - k = n$

and again this contradicts our assumption that no subset $S_i$ of $S$ has as many as $\left \lceil {n/k} \right \rceil$ elements.


Either way, there has to be at least $\left \lceil {n/k} \right \rceil$ elements in at least one $S_i \subseteq S$.

$\blacksquare$


Historical Note

This principle has been attributed to Johann Lejeune Dirichlet.

It is also known as Dirichlet's Box (or Drawer) Principle, or, as Dirichlet named it, Schubfachprinzip (drawer principle or shelf principle).

In Russian and some other languages, it is known as the Dirichlet principle, which name ambiguously also refers to the minimum principle for harmonic functions.


Source of Name

It is known as the Pigeonhole Principle because of the following.

Suppose you have $n + 1$ pigeons, but have only $n$ holes for them to stay in. By the Pigeonhole Principle at least one of the holes houses two pigeons.


Sources